Following Allegations of Misconduct, Booker, Cleaver, Kind Urge Treasury Inspector General for “Complete Review” of Treasury’s Implementation of Opportunity Zones
Following Allegations of Misconduct, Booker, Cleaver, Kind Urge Treasury Inspector General for “Complete Review” of Treasury’s Implementation of Opportunity ZonesOctober 31, 2019
WASHINGTON, D.C. — U.S. Senator Cory Booker (D-NJ) and U. S. Representatives Emanuel Cleaver, II (D-MO) and Ron Kind (D-WI), today urged the Department of Treasury to conduct an immediate and complete review of their actions related to all “certified opportunity zones for eligibility requirement conformance” following multiple reports of possible wrongdoing by senior administration officials in implementing the 2017 tax incentive program. The program, based upon bipartisan legislation authored by Booker, Kind, and Senator Tim Scott (R-SC), creates a tax incentive for individuals who reinvest unrealized capital gains into high-impact, long-term projects in high-poverty communities across the country.
The original legislation established a process by which governors from each state nominated high-poverty census tracts as Opportunity Zones, and the Department of Treasury was entrusted with ensuring their eligibility through a certification process, including using the most relevant data. Reporting by the New York Times over the weekend, however, alleges that senior treasury officials abdicated those duties, bending regulations, and violating the law that created opportunity zones.
In today’s letter to Department of Treasury Inspector General Eric Thorson, the lawmakers call for an investigation into the implementation of the Opportunity Zones program and demand Treasury and White House officials turn over all relevant communication to enforcement agencies and legislators about the program.
“We urge the Inspector General to do a complete review of all Treasury Department certified Opportunity Zones for eligibility requirement conformance and provide details on actions taken by agency officials not in compliance with the Opportunity Zones guidelines,” the lawmakers wrote.
“The underlying legislation, the Investing in Opportunity Act, was intended to support the growth and revitalization of our nation’s most economically underserved communities. It was not the intent of Congress for this tax incentive to be used to enrich political supporters or personal friends of senior administration officials, as recent reports indicate,” the lawmakers wrote.
“If any of these allegations prove to be true, it would be a perverse violation of public trust, a distortion of congressional intent, and a violation of federal law,” the lawmakers added.
Booker and Scott originally introduced the Investing in Opportunity Act in April 2016. A provision based on the bill was wrapped into the 2017 GOP tax bill, however, critical reporting requirements that were included in Booker and Scott’s original bill were removed from the final measure that became law in December 2017. Booker has repeatedly and aggressively pushed to restore these safeguards, including authoring a bipartisan billthat would restore the removed safeguards with Senators Scott, Maggie Hassan (D-NH), and Todd Young (R-IL) earlier this year. Booker also wrote to the Treasury earlier this month and in January urging it to adopt stronger reporting requirements for investors using the tax incentive.
The full letter is available here and below:
October 31, 2019
Richard K. Delmar
Acting Inspector General
U.S. Department of Treasury
Office of Inspector General
1500 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
Washington, DC 20220
Dear Inspector General Delmar,
We write to express our deep concern surrounding allegations of misconduct by senior officials within the Department of Treasury in the implementation of the 2017 Opportunity Zone tax incentive (P.L. 115-97). We request that the Department of Treasury’s Inspector General initiate an investigation into allegations raised in recent news reports of possible misconduct by White House and Treasury Department officials. We urge the Inspector General to do a complete review of all Treasury Department certified Opportunity Zones for eligibility requirement conformance and provide details on actions taken by agency officials not in compliance with the Opportunity Zones guidelines. Further, we request that the Inspector General assist in determining if there was any misconduct by private individuals and/or groups in violation of U.S. law, regulation, or legal holding by gathering and furnishing to enforcement authorities and Congress all relevant information on Opportunity Zone designation and regulation for review.
Following several news reports of possible wrongdoing in the implementation of Opportunity Zones, which was drafted and supported by our offices, we find it crucial that the Office of Inspector General investigate these allegations. The underlying legislation, the Investing in Opportunity Act, was intended to support the growth and revitalization of our nation’s most economically underserved communities. It was not the intent of Congress for this tax incentive to be used to enrich political supporters or personal friends of senior administration officials, as recent reports indicate.
Congress provides an important oversight role as part of the checks and balances of our democracy and that includes the Administration’s implementation of federal programs. With that in mind, we found the New York Times (NYT) report published earlier this week very distributing, especially the assertion of alleged widespread misconduct and corruption at the Treasury Department, and, in some instances, possibly under the personal direction of Secretary Steven Mnuchin himself. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act established a process by which governors from each state would nominate high-poverty census tracts in their respective states, to ensure that the place-based tax incentive would best meet the needs of their communities. Treasury was to then certify that the governor-nominated tracts met the criteria for Qualified Opportunity Zones (QOZs). The NYT report revealed that a controversial reversal regarding the eligibility of a Nevada QOZ was driven by politics and personal relationships at the expense of low-income communities. Despite originally declaring the Nevada tract ineligible, months of heavy lobbying by wealthy investors led to the “unusual decision [being] made at the personal instruction of Mr. Mnuchin” to allow for Storey County to be made eligible.
The recent reporting revealed that officials at Treasury, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), and the Community Development Financial Institutions Fund (CDFI), all expressed opposition to the decision: Annie Donovan, who previously ran the Treasury office in charge of designating areas as Opportunity Zones, said Treasury officials were “troubled” by the unusual action by the Secretary. An internal memo to the Treasury Secretary warned that such a reversal would “[open] the door for accusation that the determination process was influenced by political consideration or bias”. Despite these warnings from staff, Secretary Mnuchin instructed Treasury officials to allow the otherwise ineligible tract to qualify for the incentive. If the Treasury Department provided a stamp of approval as a political favor, it is not only unacceptable, but in complete violation of the congressional intent of the Opportunity Zones.
This report follows an October 24, 2019 ProPublica article on Dan Gilbert, founder of Quicken Loans, that alleged coordination with White House officials to ensure his real estate properties were included in a designated opportunity zone. In an email obtained by ProPublica, Michigan economic development official, Christine Roeder, asked her colleague to call Quicken Loans’ executive vice president for government affairs about opportunity zones and writing, “They worked with the White House on it and want to be sure we are coordinated.” The article highlights that less than two weeks after the email was written, the Trump administration revised its list of census tracts that were eligible for the tax break.
We urge the Inspector General to do a complete review of all Treasury Department certified Opportunity Zones for eligibility requirement conformance. We further request that the Inspector General collect any and all communication, including but not limited to government records, notes, correspondence, and call logs, between the Treasury Department, White House administration officials, and outside entities on the subject matter of designation of census tracks as Opportunity Zones. Additionally, we request any and all communication regarding the drafting of regulations related to Opportunity Zones between the date enactment of PL 115-97 and July 15, 2019. This information should be furnished to appropriate federal enforcement agencies and Congress for review. It is imperative the Inspector General determines if any Treasury Department official helped circumvent policy or practice to personally assist a business or individual.
If any of these allegations prove to be true, it would be a perverse violation of public trust, a distortion of congressional intent, and a violation of federal law. We urge the Inspector General’s office to conduct a thorough and complete investigation of these allegations, report to Congress as well as appropriate enforcement entities your findings with all deliberate speed.
Emanuel Cleaver, II Cory A. Booker
Member of Congress United States Senator
Member of Congress